DesignedbyLara.com

Friday, March 26, 2010

Don't Kill the Messenger Book Review *Eileen Rendahl*

Melina Markowitz is a very busy woman. Not only is she working two jobs to make ends meets, but has another secret one where she doesn't get paid at all. Melina is known in the supernatural world as a messenger. Those creatures of myth and legend, such as vampires, werewolves and even imps do exist because they expect Melina to deliver packages and other messages to one another. Melina has no choice because if she ignores this call horrible things will happen to her and she'll get very sick. If only her mother had paid closer attention to her when she was three-years-old. Melina fell in their pool and almost died, but because of this near-death experience, she has developed this strange sixth sense and is one of the few in Sacramento, California available for the job.

As Melina finishes the night shift at her second job at the Sacramento City Hospital, vampire ER doctor, Alexander Bledsoe gives her a package to deliver to the head of the local vampire governing board. Melina tries to keep to herself when it comes to the sexy undead doctor, because he could gnaw on one of her arteries if he so chooses. She finds it odd that he wants her to deliver something to one of his own, but never the less she does what she's told. Before she can drop off the package, ninjas attack her in broad daylight. Melina should be able to hold her own against them because she's very skilled in martial arts and has been since she's been seven years old and works at the River City Karate and Judo with another messenger who was able to retire. Melina is given quite the beating by these ninjas and they steal the package.

She finds out the ninjas are responsible for terrorizing the city, especially the gangs by controlling Chinese vampires called kiang shi that tear gang members, limb to limb and eat their flesh. Melina witnesses this and places an anonymous call to the police. But because her undercover skills are very lacking, she is confronted by Office Ten Goodnight, who Melina nicknames Surfer Cop because of his good looks. Goodnight is onto Melina and she feels he's watching her every move, although he also seems interested in her in other ways. Dr. Bledsoe doesn't like Melina having a possible romance with Goodnight because she could let it slip about his people, among the other creatures she interacts with. There also maybe a bit of jealousy on his end. Melina is stubborn and refuses to listen to anyone, even when she's given a bloody calling card at the hospital as a warning. She continues to investigate in such places as a Taoist temple in Old Sacramento where the vampires are kept in an old crypt, controlled by a man, with a ring of bell, who can cause more bloodshed and destructions the likes of Sacramento has never seen. And when a close friend of Melina ends up dead because of her meddling, she turns to Goodnight and Bledsoe to help her stop these criminals before more innocent people die.

Don't Kill the Messenger should have been an original, thrilling urban fantasy, but what I read instead was a re-hash of every single urban fantasy I've read over the past few years. Eileen Rendahl does try something different, especially with the heroine Melina, but it didn't work because of her overall lack of a role as a messenger, which is conveniently pushed to the side because of the way Melina stumbles onto this underworld of Chinese vampires. She really does some too stupid to live moves and I really couldn't get a handle on her motivation, and her thoughts were so scattered all over the place. She comes across as more of an airhead, where one minute she's focused on something important, and then the next something very silly and immature that doesn't have anything to do with the overall story.

Melina's romance with Ted Goodnight had promise, as well as the idea of a possible love triangle including the vampire doctor Bledsoe. But because Melina is so lacking as a character, I couldn’t see why these two men would even be interested in her. Also the sex scenes seem tacked on, and the constant reasons why Melina is such a loner and how she's difficult to get alone with grated on my nerves.

The gruesome scenes with the zombie like Chinese vampires were also boring and didn't shock in anyway. At times I felt that Ms. Rehndahl was trying too hard with her writing because she knew Don't Kill the Messenger had to be different to keep the reader interested.

Because Don't Kill the Messenger didn't hold my attention, I won't be reading the second book in this series. Melina was just too flighty with her thoughts and actions, along with her overall lack of intelligence. This one is a pass. (Berkley)

Final Grade: C

A few other Don't Kill the Messenger reviews:
Bitten by Books
Book Binge
Book Lush


Katiebabs

7 comments:

The Queen B said...

I was really wanting to read this one because of some other good reviews of it, but I did notice that the plot sounds a put convoluted and Melina sounds a bit bumbling. I thought maybe she was getting good reviews because she had some other attractive and redeemable traits to make up for it. Doesn't sound like it here, lol. I'll probably still check it out, but at least I'll know what to expect :P

KMont said...

I read somewhere online, very recently, that books like this shouldn't be so complex that it pushes readers away. That the best story telling is actually deceptively simple. I think I agree with this, and it shows because I wrote a post not long ago about everything and the fantasy kitchen sink. I'm pretty weary these days especially of urban fantasy that try to pack SO much of the urban into that fantasy.

I prefer books like Rowland's current UF demon series. The stories are nicely plotted and nothing is so complex that I go "huh?" or have to double back to see where it's all going.

And bottom line, if the hero or heroine does one too many TSTL things, it's just not going to work for me.

Fiction Vixen said...

Points for trying something different? I guess it's a risk trying to break out of the box a bit though. I've read some good reviews on this one, hard to say if I'll give it a go or not. Nice review KB

Tracy said...

I read this one and really liked it. Just shows you there's something out there for everyone.

Anonymous said...

After reading your review, I'm glad my bookstore didn't have a copy this morning. I specifically looked for reviews for this book early AM because I knew I was going to buy some books today. The reviews I read were great, so I added it to the list. I did notice, however, that one review kept mentioning how many mistakes Melina makes in the book and that sent up some red flags for me. Thanks for your review.

Karen

heidenkind said...

Even the synopsis was too convoluted for me. That's always a bad sign.

Wendy said...

Heey, I liked this book! Maybe I just understand more complex stories than you. HA! *sticks out tongue and runs away*